Results: Scandals of Daniel Sickles (Part 3 of 5)
Published on 08/07/2023
Having been acquitted of the murder of his wife's lover by reason of insanity, member of the US House of Representatives Dan Sickles sought to restore his reputation through service in the Civil War. A political appointee, rather than a trained military man, he served adequately in several battles. But at the battle at Gettysburg, Sickles defied direct orders of his superior officer at great cost. (My apology for the wordiness of this survey. N/A is available for all questions.)
QUESTIONS
GO to COMMENTS
Comments
1.
1.
Leading the Union's Third Corps at Gettysburg in 1863, Major General Daniel Sickles was ordered 3 times by his Army of the Potomac Commander General George Meade to maintain his position next to Hancock's Second Corps, and cover the Round Tops on the Union left flank. Against orders and without telling anyone, Sickles moved his men forward to the Peach Orchard. Doing so stretched the defensive posture of the Corps too thin, allowing the Confederate troops to attack from multiple sides. The Third Corps was overrun, driven from the field, and 40% of the soldiers were killed. His change of position was referred to as " . . . one of the war's most stupendous blunders". Many think the only reason Sickles was not court-martialed for insubordination was because he was seriously wounded in the battle and was politically well-connected. Do you agree?
Yes
25%
509 votes
Unsure
36%
711 votes
No
7%
144 votes
N/A
32%
636 votes
2.
2.
During the assault by Lieutenant General James Longstreet's Confederate troops, Sickles' leg was struck by a cannonball and mangled beyond repair. He was carried off the field in a litter and his leg was amputated above the knee. Having heard that the Surgeon General had requested "specimens of morbid anatomy" for study to create advances in medical science, Sickles had a wooden coffin made to display his shattered right tibia and fibula in the Army Medical Museum in Washington, DC. The museum was renamed the National Museum of Health and Medicine in 1989 and was relocated to Silver Spring, MD where his leg is still on display. Sickles recovered quickly, and was back on horseback in 2 months. Do you think it took a strong will and fortitude to get back in the saddle that quickly?
Yes, I'm impressed.
24%
481 votes
Yes, he made an effort
25%
500 votes
Unsure
17%
336 votes
Not a big deal
5%
106 votes
N/A
29%
577 votes
3.
3.
Later in life, on the anniversary of having lost his leg, sometimes Sickles visited it (pictured in a newspaper woodcut) - the bones of which were now stabilized with bits of wire. He even invited guests to accompany him. After having joined him on one such occasion, author Mark Twain stated, ". . . the general valued his lost leg away above the one that is left". Do you think Sickles' visiting his leg was eccentric?
Eccentric? That's CREEPY!
28%
552 votes
Visiting the leg was okay, but taking guests was over the top.
13%
261 votes
Who am I to judge?
21%
420 votes
I sort of understand. He was wistful.
7%
134 votes
N/A
32%
633 votes
4.
4.
Major General Sickles stayed in the army through the duration of the war, but General Ulysses S Grant didn't allow him to return to combat command. After he retired in 1869, Sickles became the US Minister to Spain, continuing his scandalous behavior by having an affair with deposed Queen Isabella II. In 1871 Sickles, 52, married twenty-something Carmina (Caroline) Creagh (pictured), one of the queen's attendants. The couple had a daughter Eda, and a son (George) Stanton Sickles, named after lawyer Edwin Stanton, who defended Daniel at his murder trial. Would you want to name your child something that was a reminder of dark times?
Sure, Sickles was very grateful to his attorney for getting an acquittal.
8%
160 votes
I don't think using the name Stanton reminded him of the trial.
5%
107 votes
No, I would not want any connection to that dark time.
25%
490 votes
No, I would find it upsetting to be reminded of the murder trial.
7%
136 votes
No, I would not want to saddle my son with a name that could remind people that I had killed my spouse's lover.
17%
340 votes
N/A
38%
767 votes
COMMENTS