Results: Have Yourself A Very Secular Christmas
Published on 12/25/2020
QUESTIONS
GO to COMMENTS
Comments
1.
1.
Christmas has become more and more a secular holiday celebration than a purely religious one. Although Christmas is celebrated by virtually all Christians, only two-thirds see it as a religious holiday. They are less likely to attend Christmas religious services and to believe in the virgin birth. And most non-Christians see the holiday as more of a social event than a religious occasion. Do you celebrate Christmas in your home?
Yes, and I am Christian
57%
1210 votes
Yes, even though I am not Christian
20%
413 votes
No, and I am Christian
8%
167 votes
No, not Christian
15%
323 votes
2.
2.
As a Jewish child, growing up, we always "adopted" the secular meaning of the holiday, and gathered together on Christmas day, exchanging gifts, feasting on a huge dinner with family and friends, enjoying the time together. We didn't equate the holiday in any way with God and certainly not with Jesus. Most of the classic songs and movies that celebrate Christmas don't even mention God or Jesus. Santa doesn't check church attendance to decide whether he's going to give a child a present—he checks whether she's been naughty or nice. He's the perfect secular judge of moral fibre. I heard this song years ago when my daughter was in grade 9 at a country school, and it instantly became my favourite Christmas song. It talks of Christmas as being more of a feeling of love and hope, and that Christmas means a lot of different things to many people. Have you ever heard this song and do you like it as much as I do?
I have heard it and also love it
21%
450 votes
I have heard it, and not that fond of it
7%
157 votes
I just heard it now, and like it
21%
446 votes
I just heard it now, and not that fond of it
9%
188 votes
Could not/did not listen to song
41%
872 votes
3.
3.
When it comes to Christmas songs, no one does it better than the Jews! Many of our best loved Christmas songs were written by Jews, and many have released top selling Christmas albums. Which of these famous Christmas songs did you know were written by Jews?
White Christmas by Irving Berlin
31%
655 votes
Silver Bells by Jay Livingston and Ray Evans
18%
388 votes
Rudolph, The Red-Nosed Reindeer by Johnny Marks -- also wrote "Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree," "A Holly Jolly Christmas," "Silver and Gold" and "Run Rudolph Run."
20%
422 votes
The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire)" by Robert Wells and Mel Tormé (yes, both Jewish)
19%
401 votes
Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow! by Sammy Cahn and Jule Styne
18%
373 votes
It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year by Edward Pola and George Wyle
13%
279 votes
Santa Baby by Joan Javits and Philip Springer
10%
213 votes
All of them
19%
391 votes
None
44%
924 votes
4.
4.
Which of these Christmas albums, all released by Jews, do you like?
Barbara Streisand – A Christmas Album
13%
271 votes
Bob Dylan – Christmas in the Heart
8%
173 votes
Carole King – Love For Christmas
8%
174 votes
Neil Diamond – A Cherry Cherry Christmas
13%
279 votes
Barry Manilow – Because it's Christmas
12%
260 votes
Harry Connick Jr. – When My Heart Finds Christmas
11%
239 votes
Phil Spector – A Christmas Gift to You from Phil Spector
4%
88 votes
Mel Torme – Christmas Songs
8%
161 votes
Bette Midler – Cool Yule
8%
165 votes
Kenny G – Miracles
9%
190 votes
All
16%
345 votes
None
49%
1042 votes
COMMENTS